Mike Matlack is the founder of Matlack & Company, a family-owned insurance agency built on relationships, trust, and a commitment to helping people protect what matters most. Since founding the company in 1985, Mike has focused on creating an insurance experience centered on service, guidance, and long-term customer relationships rather than one-size-fits-all solutions.
Over the years, Matlack & Company has grown while staying true to the values that inspired its beginnings, treating customers like neighbors, offering dependable advice, and helping individuals and businesses make informed decisions with confidence.
Building a Business on Relationships
When Mike founded Matlack & Company in 1985, his vision was to create a local insurance agency where customers felt supported and understood. Insurance decisions can feel complicated, and Mike believed people deserved clear communication, honest recommendations, and a team that took time to understand their needs.
That approach became the foundation of the company's growth. What started as a local business developed into a trusted agency serving customers with a broad range of insurance solutions while maintaining a personal, community-focused atmosphere.
As a family-owned company, Matlack & Company reflects many of the same values that matter most to Mike personally: trust, consistency, and putting people first.
A Commitment to Service and Choice
Under Mike's leadership, Matlack & Company has built relationships with more than 32 insurance carriers, giving customers access to a wide range of coverage options and competitive pricing. Rather than limiting clients to a single provider, this approach allows the agency to help identify solutions that align with each customer's specific goals and circumstances.
The agency provides a variety of insurance services, including car insurance, homeowners insurance, personal insurance, business insurance, and commercial coverage options. Policy bundling opportunities also allow customers to explore more comprehensive protection while potentially reducing overall costs.
Mike has always believed that insurance should feel approachable and practical. His focus has been on helping customers understand their coverage options and feel confident in the decisions they make.
Throughout the years, Mike has remained focused on making insurance feel personal rather than transactional. He understands that coverage decisions often happen during important life moments: buying a home, starting a business, adding a vehicle, or planning for the future. By emphasizing responsiveness, education, and individualized support, Mike has helped create an agency experience centered on trust and long-term relationships rather than quick transactions. That customer-first mindset continues to shape how Matlack & Company serves its community today.
Growing Through Experience and Community
Since its founding, Matlack & Company has remained rooted in the local community while continuing to evolve alongside the changing insurance landscape. Mike understands that protecting a home, vehicle, family, or business is not simply about policies; it's about helping people prepare for the unexpected and move forward with greater peace of mind.
That perspective has helped shape a team of trained professionals committed to providing strong customer service and responsive support. Through years of experience and a focus on relationships, the agency continues to serve customers with the same principles that guided its beginning.
Family First
Outside of work, Mike's priorities remain centered around family. As a grandfather, he values time spent with loved ones and appreciates the moments that bring generations together. Family has always been an important influence in both his personal life and the culture of the business.
Mike also enjoys golfing and appreciates the opportunity to spend time outdoors, unwind, and enjoy friendly competition. Another favorite tradition is heading down to the Jersey Shore, where time with family and familiar places offers a chance to relax and recharge.
These personal values connect closely to the work he has built over the years. Mike understands that many of the decisions people make around insurance ultimately come back to protecting the people and experiences that matter most.
Continuing a Family Legacy
Today, Matlack & Company continues to reflect the values Mike established when he founded the agency in 1985. As a local, family-owned business based in Glendora, New Jersey, the company remains focused on delivering reliable insurance solutions backed by knowledgeable guidance and attentive service.
Mike Matlack's leadership has always emphasized relationships, trust, and helping customers feel supported through every stage of life. Through decades of dedication and a strong commitment to family and community, he has built more than an insurance agency; he has created a business grounded in service and designed to help people protect what matters most. To get started with Mike Matlack and his excellent team, give us a call today. We look forward to showing you the Matlack & Company difference!
